Submitted 10 days ago

By Reserve Fan

From Atlanta

Verified Buyer

Submitted as part of a sweepstakes entry

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Pillow Top Soft

Only brand we buy, the reserve line is awesome.

Submitted 10 days ago

By Rested and happy

From Mauldin, SC

Verified Buyer

Submitted as part of a sweepstakes entry

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Duet Tight Top Firm

Struggled with finding a mattress that was just right, the medium lux estate elite was just what I needed!

Submitted 14 days ago

By Another Happy Sleeper

From Orlando, Florida

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Tight Top Medium

My goal was to invest in my sleep. And I was thrilled to have a high end mattress after trying out several in store. However, the first few months on my big splurge were not what I expected. The mattress was hard. I was not comfortable. After reading reviews telling me to wait up to 3 months for the mattress to break in, I was prepared for that. But it took much longer, closer to 5 months. For context, I'm about 135 pounds and travel some for work, so I miss some nights on the bed. I'm sensory sensitive for sure, so my experience may be more impactful than others. I was frustrated and even had my husband walking on my side during the day! Was initially convinced we got the wrong model! It's all better now and there is no doubt…The wait was worth it! My mattress is fantastic. It's my absolute favorite place and is a split with adjustable base. We are both so happy and sleep better than ever. Give it time. You will love it!

Submitted 18 days ago

By Will

From Oracle, Arizona

Verified Buyer

Submitted as part of a sweepstakes entry

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Pillow Top Soft

Sweet dreams on a pillow top

Submitted 18 days ago

By Highly disappointed

From Indianapolis

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Tight Top Medium

Unfortunately, this bed was a gift. As soon as I sat on it, I knew I didn't like it. I slept on it anyway and it didn't fit my body. It's like if you piled up a bunch of blankets layer by layer and slept on top of them. I tossed and turned. I have no idea why they call it 'luxury'. I've had far better sleep on two-star hotel mattresses. As for now, I'm sleeping in my guest bedroom. I hope I can sell this thing secondhand for a good price.

Submitted 21 days ago

By Happy Sleeper

From Palisades Park NJ

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Pillow Top Firm

My husband and I just received the Reserve 17" firm pillowtop for a split king adjustable base. It is the best mattress I've ever slept on, combining luxury & comfort. This is the first time in 17 years that my husband has been able to sleep in a bed due to back problems & pain. It has transformed our lives - sleep is so important for overall health. We wake up well rested & pain free. This mattress is top of the line & worth every penny!! There is no price on sleep.

Submitted 1 month ago

By Princess Pea

From Anderson, IN

Verified Buyer

Submitted as part of a sweepstakes entry

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Pillow Top Firm

I think I've finally found the best mattress I have ever owned! I'm no longer waking up in pain, and can sleep through the night without tossing and turning. This is by far the heaviest mattress I've ever had, so making the bed the first time was humorous. I wasn't expecting the corners to be that heavy, but I was able to work it out! Definitely would recommend, and have been bragging about it to anyone who will listen.

Submitted 1 month ago

By Sleeping well

From Springboro Ohio

Verified Buyer

Submitted as part of a sweepstakes entry

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Pillow Top Firm

We've been sleeping on this mattress for a couple of weeks now. I can honestly say both me and my husband have been able to sleep the entire night! No backaches or discomfort. This mattress with its pillow top and firmness are perfect. It's also a beautiful well made mattress. Will never buy anything else.

Submitted 2 months ago

By JCB

From Fredericksburg, TX

Verified Buyer

Submitted as part of a sweepstakes entry

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Pillow Top Soft

We are hard to please when it comes to mattresses ... and we have tried them all. My spouse has many aches and pains stemming from injuries in her past, compounded by significant fibromialgia. She needs a soft, yet supportive mattress to give her an opportunity to relax enough to sleep. Nothing we have tried before made the grade despite their claims to solve all our sleep challenges. We finally pulled out all the stops and purchased a top-of-the-line Sterns and Foster Stearns & Foster® Reserve Euro Pillow Top Soft Mattress. It is everything they claim it is and more. We could not be happier with our purchase. Highly recommend.

Submitted 2 months ago

By The Lumbar Liquefier

From Atlanta, Georgia

Reviewed at

Comments about Reserve Pillow Top Soft

If you do not care about the integrity of your spinal column, look no further than the Stearns & Foster Reserve mattress. It's as if a cabal of sleep-deprived goblins and retired chiropractors got together in a dark basement and said, "How can we ruin the human spine… but make it luxurious and overpriced?" - and thus, the Reserve was born. This is my second Stearns & Foster mattress. The first one was, ironically, the dream mattress. It was supportive, durable, and the best sleep I'd ever had. When they stopped making it, we decided to upgrade to their alleged flagship model: The Reserve. It was a splurge, but we trusted the brand. Huge mistake. The Reserve is a monstrosity. It's comically heavy - I am reasonably young and in good shape, but I can't even lift the corners to change the sheets. But this issue is exacerbated by the lower back pain that unavoidably comes when you sleep on a mattress that offers literally zero support. It's ridiculously soft. This level of softness does not occur in nature. It was concocted by the devil itself. Since getting it, both my partner and I have developed back, shoulder, and hip problems. I now visit a chiropractor twice a week just to recover from sleeping. Anecdotally, and by way of example, I recently slept on a piece of foam on a boat for 10 days - my back pain disappeared. That should tell you everything you need to know. To top it off, when I reached out to S&F to exchange the mattress for the firmer model, I was told we were 17 days too late. Their 90-day return policy is inflexible, unforgiving, and completely customer-hostile. No discretion, no escalation, no human consideration - just a flat "no." The policy is not a policy - it is a punishment. This mattress has cost us thousands of dollars and countless nights of pain. Stearns & Foster went from a brand I swore by to one I will warn others to avoid at all costs. It's overpriced, overhyped, and underdelivers in every possible way. The Reserve isn't just a disappointment—it's a cautionary tale. A very expensive, sleep-deprived cautionary tale. I've decided to rename it: The Scoliosis Suite by Stearns & Foster